Oral Arguments Today in Bottineau District Court for NWLA Lawsuit

Derrick is in Bottineau today for oral arguments related to a lawsuit challenging state law related to underground carbon dioxide storage. From the North Dakota Monitor‘s article:

The Northwest Landowners Association alleges the two laws regulating use of pore space for underground storage in North Dakota, passed in 2009 and 2021, are unconstitutional.


A key provision contained in both laws is being challenged by the group. That provision allows the North Dakota Industrial Commission to forcibly include the pore space of nonconsenting landowners in a proposed storage project if the owners of at least 60% of the project area have already consented. Nonconsenting landowners are guaranteed to be “equitably compensated,” as determined by the Industrial Commission.


The North Dakota Constitution requires a property owner receive “just compensation,” as determined by a jury and precedent, if their private property is taken or damaged for public use.


The landowner group asserts the discrepancies between the law and the constitution — namely that the law does not require “just compensation” and has the Industrial Commission decide payment instead of a jury — make the laws and resulting permitting process unconstitutional.


“This blatant attempt to bypass constitutional and other safeguards for private property is arbitrary,” the association stated in a court filing, later adding, “This finding is not a suitable replacement for just compensation and the safeguards guaranteed by the constitution of North Dakota.”

For more detail, check out the full article here.

Have an Immediate Need or Concern?

We excel at responding to the unexpected and have the experience necessary to ensure we are prepared when the unexpected occurs. Please contact us if you find yourself in need of astute attorneys with a passion for protecting land and its stewards.